
The tagline of this blog includes “beyond Madge”, I am aware. But this is a music gallery geared towards gay men, and she can’t be avoided. Look, when you think of “gay music”, Madonna is obviously going to spring to mind. So we all need to get past it and focus on one thing: Madonna is capable of releasing really enjoyable albums.
Many Madonna enthusiasts (of which I am not, let’s just air that out now) have made the argument that “Ray Of Light” was her Sistine Chapel, and I would say it’s a fair statement. And while I enjoyed “Ray Of Light” a great deal, I think “Confessions on a Dancefloor” is just as well-orchestrated if for one simple reason: it was Madonna’s last hurrah.
Prior to COADF, she had dropped “American Life” - nobody’s 2-decent-track favorite. The music had no bearing in what was happening. And for an artist that was always in the midst of what’s happening, that was like… double sad. I don’t know if she learned from that flop, or if she decided to just change our perceptions rather than fitting into them, but COADF was seemingly exactly what everyone needed when it happened.
In a word: it made club music enjoyable and interesting again. And the album itself is just damn strong all around. From the mood, to the cover art, to how it was promoted… oh and the songs are pretty fun too. The very first Madonna album where I was not skipping tracks after the first few listens.
By today’s standards, the dance songs on COADF seem to fall flat. It’s evolved into an “easy listening” dance album.
I just wish she had stopped there. “Hard Candy” produced so much second hand embarrassment, that it made me appreciate COADF that much more. How could the same artist re-launch a sub-genre… and then play “catch up” with the same genre, one album later? Seriously, 4 minutes to save the world? I can’t even get myself started.
When Madonna isn’t trying to be a rock-star, belting out ballads, acting, or altogether veering away from her strengths, then she is tolerable. The bitch just needs to stick with what she does best: make music that we can get ready/work out/dance to, and stir a bit of nonsense controversy in the process in order to call yourself an ‘artist’. Everything else is annoying.
In this way, COADF was her last moment to be super-relevant. It’s all been downhill since so, savor this one for what it was.